big fish advice

[big phil 123]

hi lads just my opinion but does anyone agree there should be a large fish limit anything over a certain size should be returned to live on that 42 lb cod is a amazing fish and seems a shame to kill it to eat???? alot of cod there i just think this would allow the bigger fish to keep getting bigger insted of cutting the chain any thoughts?

 

[toonboymc]

dont think many if anyone would release a fish like that caught in england m8 yes its alot of fish n chip suppers but you never get sick of fresh cod

 

[big phil 123]

i know but once you have the photos thats all you need just seems a shame to kill something of that size and age but explains why everyone complains about the poor fishing

 

[big phil 123]

i release most fish i catch inless its around the 4lb mark bigger and smaller goes back there the best size eating fish

 

[KeithB]

There's the other school of thought, killing a fish that size will stop it eating a lot of smaller fish.

 

[big phil 123]

yea your right cant argue with that not looking to argue just seeing other people opinions

 

[quagmire51]

If its over minimum size then it's your catch and your dilemma only.

 

[big phil 123]

i know that but in my opinion

 

[super-MAGuire]

larger fish can produce significantly larger number of eggs, in theory it is the best thing to day... reality it is never going to happen, but a 40lb fish would beable to produce 2000 times the numbers of eggs than a 20lb fish. I think the americans and new zealand have alot of maximum length catch limit.

 

[big phil 123]

i know america def have max limits on sharks

 

[john/r]

although releasing a fish and see it stroll off in the distance i still would like to know how many actualy live on normaly as if nothing has happened.

do they actualy survive even when you see them swim off,

prob is lots of fish get dropped of piers ie put back but how many survive most i imagine dont .
stress of geting dragged in hooks pulled out of them then sometimes dropped from good hieghts/

certainly makes me wunder

 

[markgg]

well I know when I was fly fishing you could hook a wee brown trout, take a tiny nick from its fin(identification purposes) and a week later still catch the same little bugger. Besides I was watching river monsters the other night and the guy explained how there are loads of fish still living with hooks in there bellies, to prove this they scanned fish with a device that showed the hook. Although I was told that if you handle mackie your natural greese on your hands removes a film of slime and the fish dies sometimes. Whities sometimes look a bit sick when returned!!!! catch and release is good in my opinion, fish should not be wasted!!!

 

[Philysafc]

If caught at depth cod and ling and the likes have swim bladders which fill with air and they just float on the top and can't get down , it's like our bends but reverse . I've seen 10lb plus ling spin at the top and throw the hook only to float and be pecked by seagulls untill we've moved round and gaffed them , shame really coz such a great fish should swim again . But would ya and could ya ? Shore caught no probs , good debate tho

 

[wonmorehoy]

Big fish advice?

Get a bigger priest.

Good luck to the lad with the 42 pounder.

 

[lingking]

its a good post by the big lad,:exclam:nice to see no ones tried to force there point of view in the discussion

dont know what the devil i would do in that situation,knowing it wouldnt go to waste --- knowing it would eat smaller fish---- knowing it would produce lots of fish ---- knowing a flipping trawler might get it tomorrow
knowing it would cost a fortune to get it stuffed



roll on the day i have to decide

 

[billfish4853]

its a good post by the big lad,:exclam:nice to see no ones tried to force there point of view in the discussion

dont know what the devil i would do in that situation,knowing it wouldnt go to waste --- knowing it would eat smaller fish---- knowing it would produce lots of fish ---- knowing a flipping trawler might get it tomorrow
knowing it would cost a fortune to get it stuffed



roll on the day i have to decide

hear hear

 

[big phil 123]

now stuffing it sounds good would have that on the wall and there are arguments on both sides the feeling to get a fish that size must be amazing but would like to know the pros and cons of killing releasing lol

 

[wonmorehoy]

now stuffing it sounds good would have that on the wall and there are arguments on both sides the feeling to get a fish that size must be amazing but would like to know the pros and cons of killing releasing lol

I'd say it's no good releasing it after you'd killed it and if you're cod fishing, you aren't after stocked carp in a puddle in a farmer's field, so if you're thinking of putting it back before it's on the hook you're in the wrong branch of the sport.

 

[big phil 123]

i ment killing,releasing not killing it then releasing lol

 

[wonmorehoy]

i ment killing,releasing not killing it then releasing lol

I knew that. I was pulling your leg.