Have We Forgot The Spirit Of NESA?

[Safetyman]

Although its not my site and has nowt to do with me. One idea I've seen on other forum is people get a weeks ban or a month depending on the severity. Repeat offenders get longer or permanent. Don't know if this is an idea that could be used here?

Good idea and it might work giving people time to cool off and think about what has been said.

One thing I find amazing (and this is not knocking the great job the moderators do) is that we are never told that a member has been banned and why. If we are to learn from people's mistakes surely we should know what mistakes they have made

Additionally I have had a couple of posts removed but never told why. How can I stop posting offensive posts if I am never told what is wrong with them???

A simple email to the offending person informing them their behaviour, attitude or words are wrong and why it is wrong can't be too difficult? That might stop some of these war of words getting out of control and members getting banned

[Pighunter]

Good idea and it might work giving people time to cool off and think about what has been said.

One thing I find amazing (and this is not knocking the great job the moderators do) is that we are never told that a member has been banned and why. If we are to learn from people's mistakes surely we should know what mistakes they have made

Additionally I have had a couple of posts removed but never told why. How can I stop posting offensive posts if I am never told what is wrong with them???

A simple email to the offending person informing them their behaviour, attitude or words are wrong and why it is wrong can't be too difficult? That might stop some of these war of words getting out of control and members getting banned

Read the rules it states in there what can't be said or done

[Safetyman]

Read the rules it states in there what can't be said or done

I did when I joined but it still doesn't tell you who got banned and why or why my posts were deleted.

[garyp]

this info may have helped?

some members may be still here if they did the following

"Dealing with Troublesome Users
Can I block posts, emails and messages from specific users?

If there are particular members that bother you and you do not want to see their posts or receive Private Messages and Emails from them, then you can add these members to your 'Ignore List'. There are several ways to do this:

Through your User Control Panel: User CP, Settings & Options, Edit Ignore List. Then, type their name into the empty text box and click 'Okay'."

[mark]

If t was me I would start to kick people who cause issues.... Some of these posts run far too long before being deleted etc. people behave like fools, kick em.

benefit of the doubt for a short while. Don't like banning folks, but has to be done sometimes. If mods were quick to pull the trigger there'd be even more complaints, so we let it go for a while, see if the user can pull themselves back then they are gone if they don't. It's not easy finding a happy medium

some of us have been here 14/15 years or more. Seen more hassles, and had to ban more people in the last year than all the previous years together. the first 10 years probably saw maybe only one person banned that I can remember. maybe 2.

I don't think naming/shaming banned people by publishing the who's and why's is very productive and doesn't achieve anything except open a debate as to the reasons and probably see the whole thing brought back to the boil. So they go, thats an end to it.

Not long ago after several were shown the door, someone started a thread immediately as to the why/wherfores. The original arguement started again in that thread and resulted in someone else going the journey

I saw more reported post emails and PM'd complaints about the last particular one than any previously. I did stick a thread up last year trying to be lighthearted, the old yellow card red card mallarkey. made no difference

give an eejit enough rope they will still hang themselves

Spirit of NESA is very much alive and well. Its a 2 way street though. You only get out, what you put in.

[The Great Wallsendo]

For me the thread below is the true spirit of NESA...I joined up in 2007 (I applied for an allotment that year too...) keen to get back into a hobby I had not taken part in since I was a kid

I created a snappy internet username, asked a load of questions and made new friends...not just "internet" friends but peeps I met in real life and went fishing with

Here we are 7 years down the road and I still fish alongside the same friends on shore and on the boat (and I'm up to 14th on the waiting list for the allotment LOL)

http://www.nesa.co.uk/forums/boat-catch-reports/13987-slinky-kate-wallsedno-22nd-july-2007-a.html

[lead chucker]

Like finding hens teeth them allotments! Well at least your not vegetating on the allotment lol

[Ian Alexander]

Great post Ian, you should reinstate it.

I agree this place just isn't as friendly as it used to be.

Maybe that's down to the membership increase, or maybe the lack of previous admins like Jim or Tony who devoted a lot of time to the site and organised events.

Thanks Keith, I thought about the post a little while after I'd posted it and thought "why bother? people seem quite happy so maybe it's just me".....so I removed it.

Probably best to just ignore the daft posts and hijacked threads as a few have mentioned.

I'll probably just watch from afar for a while, I don't contribute as much as I did a while ago anyway.

Regards Ian

[kayos]

benefit of the doubt for a short while. Don't like banning folks, but has to be done sometimes. If mods were quick to pull the trigger there'd be even more complaints, so we let it go for a while, see if the user can pull themselves back then they are gone if they don't. It's not easy finding a happy medium

some of us have been here 14/15 years or more. Seen more hassles, and had to ban more people in the last year than all the previous years together. the first 10 years probably saw maybe only one person banned that I can remember. maybe 2.

I don't think naming/shaming banned people by publishing the who's and why's is very productive and doesn't achieve anything except open a debate as to the reasons and probably see the whole thing brought back to the boil. So they go, thats an end to it.

Not long ago after several were shown the door, someone started a thread immediately as to the why/wherfores. The original arguement started again in that thread and resulted in someone else going the journey

I saw more reported post emails and PM'd complaints about the last particular one than any previously. I did stick a thread up last year trying to be lighthearted, the old yellow card red card mallarkey. made no difference

give an eejit enough rope they will still hang themselves

Spirit of NESA is very much alive and well. Its a 2 way street though. You only get out, what you put in.

Couldn't agree more Mark. A mod makes a decision, end of story. You have a hard enough job with having to explain the whys and wherefores. I allowed myself to get wound up by a couple posts last year, but quickly realised I had to pull my head in or lose my membership.

This is the best site on the web, by far! I came on here knowing only what I remembered from fishing as a young guy on the Clyde. I have learned so much from members, regarding boat fishing and places to fish from the shore in the NE. Guys willing to meet us when we come down and as someone else said you become not just internet friends but actually meet up. I might not catch many fish, but I would miss being a member dreadfully. Compare this site with the secrecy and in fighting on other sites and you can see how great this NESA is.

In my opinion the only other site worth a membership is SAR. Obviously it has way less members, but a good friendly site none the less. NESA has a great set of lads and if a few take things too far, then they will get banned eventually. Ignore the "daft" threads and just read what interests you and you can't go wrong on here

Now if only I could catch some damn fish!

Keep up the great work NESA.

[fishingmark]

Ignore the "daft" threads and just read what interests you and you can't go wrong on here

Spot on.

[onefortheroad]

the ignore user option is the best bet .